University
Brain Has an Innate Sense of Geometry
By Carl Marziali on November 17, 2009 7:34 AM
- USC College professor Irving Biederman measured subjects’ sensitivity to “non-accidental” properties of objects.
- Photo/Philip Channing
Despite minimal exposure to the regular geometric objects found in developed countries, African tribal people perceive shapes as well as westerners, according to a new study.
The findings, published online in an “Early View” edition of Psychological Science, suggested that the brain’s ability to understand shapes develops without the influence of immersion in simple, manufactured objects.
“In terms of perceiving the world … either genetics or the natural world will give you the right type of experiences,” said lead author Irving Biederman, an expert on perception and the Harold Dornsife Professor of Neuroscience at USC College.
Biederman and his team specifically measured subjects’ sensitivity to “non-accidental” properties of objects, such as whether they have straight or curved edges.
A theory of shape recognition developed by Biederman holds that the brain is more sensitive to non-accidental properties - which stay the same as an object rotates in space - than to metric properties that vary with orientation.
In one experiment, subjects were asked to identify which of two geometric objects was an exact match to a sample object. The one that didn’t match differed either in a non-accidental or metric property.
The researchers found that Western college students and members of the semi-nomadic Himba tribe of northwestern Namibia, a rural area bordering Angola, both showed greater sensitivity to non-accidental properties.
The findings have an incidental implication: Parents can probably toss the beloved shape sorter on the large heap of educational toys toddlers do not really need.
Shape sorters may have other potential benefits such as fine motor training. And some children simply enjoy them. But Biederman questioned the main advertised benefit of the toys.
“Your kids will grow up being able to see shapes just fine without specific training,” he said.
Most members of the Himba have never seen a computer or television, do not use a phone and have only handmade tools, Biederman said.
The Himba also lack words for many shapes, including squares, circles and triangles.
Nevertheless, Himba and university student volunteers responded virtually identically to variations in shape in sorting experiments on a laptop computer.
“The bottom line is that the Himba differ not at all from individuals living in what is, arguably, the most artifactual of environments [Los Angeles],” the authors stated.
“The experiment offers, to our knowledge, the most rigorous assessment of the effects of exposure to modern artifacts on the representation of shape.”
The research team went deep into tribal territory to find nomadic groups that would have had almost no contact with manufactured objects. Each six-day excursion in a four-wheel drive vehicle took the research team a full day’s drive or more from Opuwo, the last township on the edge of Himba lands.
Biederman’s collaborators were USC graduate students Xiaomin Yue and Mark Lescroart along with Jules Davidoff of the University of London. The National Science Foundation funded the research.
The Psychological Science study is available to subscribers at http://www3.interscience.wiley.com/journal/121537669/issue.
A related study in the journal Visual Cognition is available to subscribers at http://www.informaworld.com/smpp/content~db=all?content=10.1080/13506280802507806.
Print publication of both studies is expected this winter.
TAGS: humanities, research
Latest University stories
- Fall Applications Up Slightly at USC February 9, 2010 8:12 AM
- For-Profit Colleges Focus of New Book February 9, 2010 8:08 AM
- USC Expands Military Social Work Education February 9, 2010 7:45 AM
-
For Journalists »
-
USC in the News
for 2/6 to 2/8/2010 »-
Los Angeles Times featured the USC Rossier School’s centennial gala, which took place February 1. USC President Steven B. Sample was honored with the Global Education Leadership Award, and USC alumna Cindy McCain was honored with the Dean’s Alumni Achievement Award. “It’s rare for someone who’s lived as long as I have in politics with my husband to be speechless, but I truly am,” McCain said. Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa introduced Sample, recounting his work in raising USC’s stature globally, being open to international students, and understanding USC’s position in Los Angeles as “the gateway to Asia and Latin America.” Nearly 350 people attended the event, including Sen. John McCain; Ed Roski, chairman of the USC Board of Trustees; Barbara and Roger Rossier, for whom the Rossier School is named; John Katzman, Princeton Review founder and benefactor of an endowed chair at the Rossier School; and alumni and longtime USC supporters Debbie and J. Terrence Lanni and Verna Dauterive.
The Chronicle of Higher Education included USC in a chart on international fundraising by higher education institutions. USC has received $2.9 million from international philanthropic funds, and is estimated to have more than 6,000 foreign alumni, the story stated.
The Chronicle of Higher Education featured Paul Debevec of USC’s Institute for Creative Technologies, who won an Academy Award for co-creating a light stage capture device and image-based facial rendering system that has been used in movies like “Avatar.” The award will be presented at a formal dinner on February 20, the story noted. Asked whether the technology could be applied to education, Debevec said: “Absolutely, yes. Maybe there’s a little rendering of a chemistry professor at the side of the screen who smiles at you when you get the question right and frowns when you get the question wrong. [In perhaps 10 years] that computer might, through its Web cam, look back at you, see where you’re looking on the screen, see how engaged you are, and actually adapt itself to trying to teach you in the way that it seems to be working the best. Just like one-on-one tutoring.”
The Chronicle of Higher Education featured linguist Paul Frommer of the USC Marshall School, who created the language Na’vi for the Golden Globe-winning movie “Avatar.” “Doing this kind of work as an academic is not going to advance your research reputation. It’s not going to result in publications in peer-reviewed journals,” Frommer said. “But it just may push the world forward in the way it’s turning on young people to the wonders of language”
Los Angeles Times reported that the 22nd annual USC Libraries Scripter Award was given to “Up in the Air” novelist Walter Kirn and to USC alumnus Jason Reitman and Shelton Turner, who adapted Kirn’s book for the screen. Los Angeles Times ran a second story about the Scripter Award.
-
-
Campus News
- Capital Connections
- USC faculty, staff and alumni in Washington, D.C., and Sacramento
- In Print
- New and recent books written or edited by USC faculty and staff
- Family Matters
- Achievements and awards
- Obituaries