Politics / Society
Attitude Is Everything in Walking Study
- USC professor Marlon Boarnet conducted a study focusing on positive and negative feelings toward walking.
- Photo/Daniel A. Anderson
By Andrew Good on January 24, 2012 12:47 PM
City planners long have debated how to get people on their feet and cars off the road. But encouraging urban dwellers to go pedestrian could require different strategies depending on their attitudes toward walking, according to USC Sol Price School of Public Policy professor Marlon Boarnet.
The research comes at a time when scholars from multiple disciplines tout the value of walking for health and environmental benefits as much as to alleviate congestion.
Boarnet, along with colleagues at Texas A&M University and The University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, recently published a study on the role attitudes play on whether people walk or drive.
What they found is that people can be split into those who are walking-oriented and those who are not. Those who don’t mind walking can be encouraged to leave their cars behind if they live in a pedestrian-friendly neighborhood with businesses accessible by foot. But environmental factors weren’t enough to influence those with negative feelings toward walking.
What’s more, little is known about the causes of those negative feelings, let alone how urban planners can address them.
“We were intrigued to find this split,” Boarnet said, adding that studies in this area largely have overlooked the role attitude plays in walking. “There are still only a few studies that look at how attitudes influence the link between the built environment and walking.”
The study, which was published in the Journal of Planning Education and Research in November, surveyed 2,125 residents in eight Los Angeles neighborhoods in the South Bay. The neighborhoods were split between being “center” oriented (older communities with development surrounding a central commercial district) and “corridor” oriented (post-World War II, suburban developments based along a main artery road). The 155-item survey included questions about the number of trips made in a day, the purpose of those trips and their mode of transportation. Respondents also were asked attitude questions, such as gauging their interest in walking to eateries on a scale of one to five.
On average, the pedestrian-friendly center neighborhoods reported more walkers than the corridors. But across the two neighborhood types, the proportion of residents with attitudes that favored walking was similar, suggesting that people do not strictly choose their residence based on attitudes about walking.
According to the study, the more shops and restaurants are located near those who enjoy walking, and the more pedestrian-friendly their neighborhood, the more they’ll go about on foot. However, having these incentives has little effect on those with negative attitudes toward walking. Likewise, disincentives to walking, like high crime rates, had a strong influence on those reporting negative walking attitudes. Crime rates had much less effect on those with positive attitudes.
The study concluded that planning scholars need to pursue a multipronged approach to promote walking: improving the built and social environment while also addressing people’s attitudes. How to best do that remains an unanswered question.
Boarnet said it’s unknown whether people’s attitudes toward travel vary over time or in differing contexts, and if so, how. For now, the research suggested that urban planners can retrofit old neighborhoods to get some people on the sidewalk, but further research is needed to understand how to influence those who are not predisposed to walk.
He also said part of the problem in the past has been a lack of communication between disciplines. Public health professionals and urban planners had been “very siloed” up until about a dozen years ago when an active effort was started to bring each of these communities together.
“There’s a community of planners that studies travel behaviors and many public health scholars trying to figure out what makes people engage in exercise or not,” Boarnet said. “The two groups have been increasingly talking over the past several years, but we are still learning how to communicate across boundaries.”
Latest Politics / Society stories
- Myers Urges Generational Unity for 2012 Election February 15, 2012 2:06 PM
- George Will Shares His Perspective on Politics February 9, 2012 1:10 PM
- NYPD Expert Breaks Down Al Qaeda's Plots February 7, 2012 9:20 AM
-
For Journalists »
-
USC in the News
for 2/22/2012 »-
The New York Times highlighted the USC Libraries Scripter Awards, noting that “The Descendants” took the prize for the best adapted screenplay of the year. Screenwriters Alexander Payne, Nat Faxon and Jim Rash accepted the award with novelists Kaui Hart Hemmings this past Saturday at USC’s Doheny Memorial Library. Variety reported that USC Libraries Dean Catherine Quinlan served as mistress of ceremonies, feigning dismay over the lack of library-centric films. “Where are all the library movies?” she said. The awards were also covered by United Press International, The Times-Picayune, two Deadline stories (second link here), The Hollywood Reporter, The Wrap, HitFix and World Entertainment News Network.
Los Angeles Business reported that the USC Rossier School’s Center for Higher Education Policy Analysis has been renamed the Earl and Pauline Pullias Center for Higher Education. The story stated that the re-naming comes after a generous undisclosed gift from the Pullias Family estate. “The Pullias Center can now expand its cutting edge research on postsecondary institutions, as well as its critical community outreach work helping underserved students get into college,” said Rossier Dean Karen Symms Gallagher. Earl Pullias was a founding faculty member of USC’s higher education department in 1957. William Tierney of the Rossier School directs the Pullias Center.
NPR’s “Talk of the Nation” interviewed David Treuer of the USC Dornsife College about his new book, “Rez Life: An Indian’s Journey Through Reservation Life.” The book centers around the reservation Treuer grew up on, and how the Native American experience is often depicted in ways that leave out the happy moments. “There’s this great disconnect between ... how we feel and how we seem,” Treuer said. Treuer’s book was also featured by Minnesota Public Radio, Star-Tribune, Appeal-Democrat, The Spectrum, Baltimore City Paper, The Bemidji Pioneer and Brainerd Dispatch.
KCET-TV featured “The Accidental Feminist” by M.G. Lord of the USC Dornsife College, a new book about the ways in which actress Elizabeth Taylor served as an early feminist icon. Lord said that she came to write the book after spending a weekend watching Taylor movies with friends; they found that in many of Taylor’s movies, she offered veiled feminist messages or embraced her own sexual desire while working within the constraints of the Motion Picture Production Code.
China Internet Information Center (China) featured a screening of the documentary “Assignment: China — The Week That Changed the World,” created by the USC U.S.-China Institute. The documentary follows the American journalists reporting on President Nixon’s historic visit to China in 1972. The institute’s Mike Chinoy narrates the documentary.
-
-
Campus News
- Capital Connections
- USC faculty, staff and alumni in Washington, D.C., and Sacramento
- In Print
- New and recent books written or edited by USC faculty and staff
- Family Matters
- Achievements and awards
- Obituaries